Supermarket loyalty prices: are the savings real? What the CMA's check of 50,000 products found

Clubcard prices, Nectar prices, member prices: loyalty pricing has become the main way big UK supermarkets advertise a discount. The obvious suspicion is that the "regular" price is padded so the member price looks generous. In November 2024 the competition regulator tested that suspicion on a large scale. Here is what it found, number by number.
- ~50,000loyalty-priced products whose price history the CMA analysed
- 92%offered a genuine saving on the usual price at that retailer
- 17–25%average saving for members, depending on the supermarket
- 61 of 429branded loyalty deals were cheaper at another supermarket
The review in one paragraph
The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) published its review of loyalty pricing in the groceries sector on 27 November 2024. It looked at five supermarkets that run loyalty price promotions, analysed pricing data for around 50,000 products sold on a loyalty "dual price" (one price for members, a higher one for everyone else), compared 429 branded products with prices at other retailers, and ran a nationally representative survey of shoppers. The question was simple: are these offers genuine, and are shoppers treated fairly?
How big loyalty pricing has become
According to the CMA's executive summary, revenue from loyalty-priced groceries at the supermarkets running such schemes was over £5 billion between November 2023 and January 2024, roughly 22% of their grocery revenue on average (the share varies by retailer). Tesco and Sainsbury's alone offer thousands of products on a loyalty price each week, and the number kept growing at most supermarkets during 2024.
Membership is almost universal. The survey found that 97% of shoppers belong to at least one supermarket scheme, and the average shopper belongs to three.
What shoppers believe
The survey numbers show a clear gap between participation and trust:
| Survey finding | Share of shoppers |
|---|---|
| Member of at least one supermarket loyalty scheme | 97% |
| Think loyalty pricing offers good savings | 69% |
| Consider it unfair that members pay less than non-members | 43% |
| Do not trust that loyalty prices are a genuine saving | 40% |
| Think non-members pay more than the usual price during a promotion | 55% |
The last line is the key one. More than half of shoppers suspect that the non-member price is pushed up while the promotion runs. That is exactly what the price data can test.
What the price data showed
On the first test, the regulator's answer is reassuring. Of the roughly 50,000 products sold on a loyalty dual price, 92% offered a genuine saving against the usual price of that product at that retailer. The CMA found "very limited evidence" of price changes that would suggest supermarkets inflate prices to make member prices look better, and non-members generally paid the same price during a promotion as in the weeks before and after it. The average member saving ranged from 17% to 25% across the five supermarkets.
On the second test, the answer is more nuanced. Loyalty prices were generally the same as, or cheaper than, the cheapest price for the same product elsewhere. But 61 of the 429 branded products examined, about one in seven, were available more cheaply at another supermarket at the time. A genuine saving in one shop is not necessarily the best price on the high street.
In plain terms: the member price is usually a real discount on that shop's own normal price. It is not a promise that nobody else sells the product for less.
Data and access: two smaller findings
Personal data worries are not what keeps people out. Only 7% of surveyed shoppers who are not members of a scheme at the shop where they regularly buy groceries gave personal data concerns as the reason, and the CMA said it had seen no evidence of consumer-law problems in how supermarkets collect and use that data.
Access is a different matter. The CMA said some supermarkets could do more so that people without a smartphone, people under 18 or people without a fixed address can join a scheme, or at least know how to get loyalty prices.
What the review does not tell you
- It is a snapshot. The analysis covers promotions up to 2024. Prices and schemes change; a fair practice then is not a guarantee now.
- "Genuine" is measured against the same shop. A saving on a usual price that was already high is still a genuine saving by this test.
- Five supermarkets only. Discounters without loyalty pricing, and smaller retailers, are outside the main analysis.
- The basket matters more than the item. A shopper chasing loyalty deals across several items may still spend more overall than in a cheaper shop with no scheme.
How to check a member price yourself
- Compare unit prices, not shelf prices. Loyalty deals often apply to particular pack sizes. The unit price (per kg, per litre, per 100 sheets) is the only way to compare. A 2023 CMA review found that some retailers were not showing unit prices for promoted products at all, a gap consumer group Which? had campaigned on, as it reported in its article on the regulator's findings. Our guide on how to read a unit price explains the pitfalls.
- Look at the non-member price after the promotion ends. If it drops, the "regular" price was not regular.
- Check one other shop for your top five items. The CMA's 61-in-429 finding suggests that for branded goods, one comparison is often worth the effort.
- Watch the pack size, not just the price. A deal on a smaller pack can hide a higher price per gram, the mechanism behind shrinkflation.
Context: the CMA's wider grocery work
The loyalty review was part of a broader programme started during the cost-of-living crisis. The CMA notes that aggregate food price inflation stood at 19.1% in March 2023. Earlier, its unit pricing project (opened January 2023, closed January 2024) found problems with how unit prices are displayed and asked the government to reform the Price Marking Order 2004. In its November 2024 summary, the CMA said the reforms had been laid before Parliament and were set to come into force in October 2025. The start date was later pushed back: according to legislation.gov.uk, the Price Marking (Amendment) Order 2024 took effect in Great Britain on 6 April 2026. Among other things, a shop that offers a member price must now show each selling price and each unit price, together with the conditions for getting the lower one. The CMA has also published guidance urging grocery retailers to make accurate pricing a priority after store inspections found errors, especially in smaller shops.
Method and sources
All figures are taken from the CMA's published executive summary and case pages, read on 22 November 2026. The only calculation of our own is 61 ÷ 429 = 14.2%, rounded to "about one in seven". We have not re-run the CMA's price analysis.
- CMA, Review of loyalty pricing in the groceries sector, and its executive summary, 27 November 2024.
- CMA, Unit pricing case page (2023–2024).
- The Price Marking Order 2004 (SI 2004/102), legislation.gov.uk.
- CMA press release, "CMA calls on grocery stores to make accurate pricing a priority".
- Which?, "Regulator clamps down on supermarket pricing following Which? campaign".
Free to reuse with a link to this page.

